One of the graver crimes committed by Indian streaming is giving modern or ‘brave’ themes the television-soap treatment. Actually, calling it television-soap treatment is reductive — and generous. It’s a crutch we use to describe algorithmic shows that have no personality. So what I really mean is this is flat storytelling bereft of curiosity and character; it seeks viewers looking for content, and therefore sets out to balance its new-age core with the most facile filmmaking possible. The fillers of a city look fake, the visuals look AI-generated, and everyone behaves like an emotion-bot; it’s a throwback to those early Voot and ALTBalaji shows, where every setting looks like a glitchy simulation of reality.
Teen Tigada (“Three’s a crowd”) is a classic case. It’s what happens when Chand Mera Dil and Mr. & Mrs. Mahi walk into a bar on a dry day and ask for a happy meal. Despite the ‘edgy’ premise, it cannot be blander and safer if it tries. The series revolves around an aspiring female cricketer who takes her eye off the ball: the talented teenager gets sidetracked by peer pressure, hormones, a random love story and an unplanned pregnancy. Over nine superficial episodes, we see her story stretched and expanded into needless directions. We see her grappling with the conflict in slow-motion, even as the series finds strange diversions to pad up a season that’s obviously building up to one question: will she abort? Or will she experience a magical epiphany about babies and motherhood and love at the very last moment?
If broad strokes were a person, it would be the protagonist of this show. The girl’s name is Asmani Joshi (‘Asmani’ as in sky-like). We know she’s the star batter of a prestigious Mumbai college (the ‘90s called, they want their spacious campus back) because the bearded coach is hard on her for no reason; it’s almost like he is auditioning to be the central character of a washed-out-coach story (a la Abhishek Bachchan in Ghoomer), but to no avail. We know the stakes for Asmani are high because the middle-classness of her sweet Maharashtrian father is the ultimate guilt tripper; he sends the bank’s loan text to her ‘by mistake,’ dreams of making her the next Smriti Mandhana, treats her as a bestie, and plans to sell his small-town business to fund her future greatness. Imagine how loudly his heart will break.
Ganpati Bappa is mentioned at least 10 times in the first episode to cement the culture she is destined to betray. We know that the boy in question, Manas (Danesh Razvi), is a wannabe dark rockstar because one of his first lines is literally “yeah I hate this fucking world”; he broods like a Vishesh Films hero but speaks like a rejected Rok Sako To Rok Lo student. The serious Asmani is taken by his wild-child ways (he punches people a lot) and his vanilla tattoos; they hook up on a terrace that’s lit like an indie house party, split up, but decide to give it a shot when they discover they’re in the same school. Early on, in the college corridor, timely renovation work ensures that actual sparks fly when their paths cross; of course she’s discussing sparks flying with her friends in this scene too.
Let’s talk about their meet-cute to understand the clumsiness of the series. She’s at a bar on a bad date, he sings on stage, she swoons, the date misbehaves, then they resort to one of those bizarre romcom gimmicks. When attacked by those rowdies on Marine Drive, he asks her if she can tango. We expect a Baazigar-like sequence where the couple blissfully swat away the men while dancing and falling for each other, but the choreography and editing are so half-baked that it looks like an advert for muscle relaxers. The tango-violence doesn’t land, to put it politely. The only nice touch is that Asmani is wired to see firecrackers as a sign of destiny (because of her memories of India winning the 2011 World Cup), so she immediately kisses him when she sees fireworks outside a wedding. The one-night stand that follows conflates awkward acting with nervous bodies.
Over the last decade, the OTT landscape has robbed romcom tropes of their charm. It’s as if most makers trade social specificity for a generic idea of chemistry. Asmani and Manas, for instance, take turns winning each other over: first him (in a girl’s washroom, then her (on a beach at sunset). They are supposed to overcome their sexual tension to pursue something romantic. But they often interact like siblings who must rely on the camera and the score to sell their sudden attachment.
The series insists that it is contemporary by presenting her two friends as girls casually in situationships with married men and multiple boys, and his flatmates as quirky buddies who occupy an apartment that looks like a designer kitchen catalogue in a showroom. There’s such dissonance between the humans and their surroundings that nothing true registers. Once the crisis begins, the show collapses into pointless chaos: all quantity, no quality. There’s an entire stretch featuring a shady abortion clinic, a cartoonish police raid, her friends trying to find out Manas’ identity, his mother dropping in, and her “mood swings” being used as a license to depict certifiably insane behaviour.
It’s not the first time Prasanna Bisht leads a social-theme show (Chiraiya was about marital rape) that gentrifies her talent. These are ambitious choices on paper, but the screen keeps letting her down. There are moments — especially as Asmani hesitates to lust for Manas — when the actor escapes the simplistic script and shows the intuition that made her stand out in Farrey (2023). But the filmmaking reduces most of the performances to live-action props. It also takes some doing to have a nine-episode season and still feel incomplete. But it’s not about what lies ahead; it’s about how the show already views its world and appropriates its conflicts under the guise of moral forwardness. There is no coming back from lowest-common-denominator storytelling, even if the intent is the selling point. You don’t need a crystal ball and automated commentary to know what happens next. The trailer alone is enough to seal its fate. And that’s never a good sign.